Human Reserve Rate observation
A Professional Task Can Be Reserved by Prohibition
専門タスクは、禁止によって保留されうる
HRR-2026-007 · public or private social scoring of natural persons · DENY · H4_RESERVED
Observation
OBSERVED TASK
public or private social scoring of natural persons
自然人の公的または私的なソーシャル・スコアリング
Source: European Union. Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, Article 5
DENY · H4_RESERVED · Observed + Inference
The classification itself is SHIRO & Co. observational interpretation. It is not an objective scientific fact.
分類自体は SHIRO & Co. の観測的解釈である。客観的な科学的事実ではない。
FACT事実
OBSERVED FACT
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (the EU Artificial Intelligence Act) prohibits placing on the market, putting into service, or using certain AI practices listed in Article 5.
- Article 5(1)(c) prohibits AI systems that evaluate or classify natural persons or groups over a period of time based on social behaviour or known, inferred or predicted personal or personality characteristics, where the resulting social score leads to detrimental or unfavourable treatment in unrelated social contexts, or to treatment that is unjustified or disproportionate to the gravity of the behaviour.
- The official recitals state that this prohibition should not affect lawful evaluation of natural persons carried out for a specific purpose in accordance with Union and national law.
- The European Commission's 2025 guidelines on prohibited AI practices treat social scoring as a distinct prohibited practice, not as a general ban on all scoring or ranking.
INTERPRETATION解釈
SHIRO & Co. INTERPRETATION
Human Reserve can be created by refusing a capable task, not only by supervising it.
A DENY classification is still a delegation decision. It locates authority in the institution that withholds permission.
Human Reserveは、能力あるタスクを監督するだけでなく、拒否することによっても作られうる。
DENY分類も委任の決定である。許可を与えない制度に権限を置く。
Uncertainty
UNCERTAINTY
- This observation records a legal reservation of a narrow practice. It does not survey how the prohibition is enforced in a specific member state.
- Purpose-specific scoring that the recitals treat as lawful is outside the observed task.
- DENY here is an institutional classification of the prohibited practice, not a claim about all ranking systems.
Signal
Capability can exist while permission is withheld.
Human Reserve question
If a task is technically feasible, what remains of Human Reserve when institutions refuse the task itself?
タスクが技術的に可能でも、制度がそのタスク自体を拒否するとき、Human Reserveには何が残るか。
Human Reserve implication
The calibration set is incomplete without a DENY case. Reserve is not only HOLD.
- Domain
- AI Governance / Fundamental Rights / Public Authority
- Observed capability
- AI systems can evaluate or classify people over time from social behaviour or inferred personal characteristics, producing a score that can then be used to treat them more or less favourably.
- Delegation state
- DENY
- Human presence
- H4 — RESERVED
- Confidence
- Observed + Inference
DENY and H4 apply to prohibited social scoring of natural persons, not to all evaluation, ranking, or credit assessment.
Delegation boundary
The observed task is denied as a prohibited AI practice under the cited EU rule. Lawful, purpose-specific evaluation of persons is explicitly placed outside that prohibition and is not classified here.
Authority boundary
Legislative and institutional authority retains the scoring practice itself. The AI system is not granted operational authority to produce a prohibited social score for use in the Union market.
Accountability boundary
Answerability for placing on the market, putting into service, or using a prohibited practice remains with the providers, deployers and public authorities named by the regulation. This record does not assign liability in a specific case.